Trademark Examination Guideline

Trademark Examination Guideline - 2021

The criteria for examining trademark applications within the scope of Industrial Property Code No. 6769 and its Implementing Regulation continue to be made available to practitioners through the Trademark Examination Guideline, published by the Turkish Patent and Trademark Office in 2021.

You may access the current version of the Guideline here.

Guideline for the Examination of Article 5 of the Industrial Property Code No. 6769

NumberTitlePage
1.Turkish Industrial Property Code Article 5/1-Ap.2
1.1.General explanationsp.2
1.1.1.Definition of a trademarkp.2
1.1.1.1.Signsp.3
1.1.1.2.Distinctive characterp.3
1.1.1.3.Representability in the registerp.4
1.2.Non-traditional trademarks and Article 5(1)(A) of the Industrial Property Codep.6
1.2.1.Three-dimensional trademarksp.7
1.2.2.Color trademarksp.8
1.2.2.1.Representation of single-color trademarks in the registerp.9
1.2.2.2.Representation of color-combination trademarks in the registerp.11
1.2.3.Representation of sound trademarks in the registerp.13
1.2.4.Representation of motion trademarks in the registerp.14
1.2.5.Position trademarksp.17
1.2.6.Pattern trademarksp.18
1.2.7.Scent trademarks / trademarks relating to the sense of smellp.18
1.2.8.Taste trademarksp.19
1.3.Relationship with other provisions of the Industrial Property Codep.20
NumberTitlePage
2.Turkish Industrial Property Code Article 5/1-Bp.21
2.1.General explanationsp.21
2.1.1.Distinctivenessp.21
2.1.2.Main principles to be taken as basis in determining distinctivenessp.22
2.1.2.1.Evaluation of the sign within the scope of the goods and services for which registration is soughtp.22
2.1.2.2.Principle of the integrity of the sign applied forp.23
2.1.2.3.Perception of the relevant consumerp.24
2.2.Special situationsp.25
2.2.1.Word trademarksp.25
2.2.1.1.Presence of the distinctive expression in a way that is not noticeable within the wholep.25
2.2.2.Word combinationsp.26
2.2.3.Applications in the form of “… master”p.29
2.2.4.“Word + device” combinationsp.30
2.2.5.Slogansp.32
2.2.6.Applications formatted as “… we love”, “… we do”, “I love …”, “I like …”, “… souvenir”p.37
2.2.7.Applications consisting of event namesp.39
2.2.8.Device trademarksp.42
2.2.8.8.Patternsp.62
2.2.8.9.Device combinationsp.65
2.2.8.10.Toys, toy dolls and play figuresp.68
2.2.9.Colour trademark applications consisting of a colour or colour combinationsp.69
2.2.9.1.Colour trademark applications consisting of a single colourp.69
2.2.9.2.Colour trademark applications consisting of colour combinationsp.72
2.2.10.Sound trademarksp.73
2.2.11.Motion trademarksp.74
2.2.12.Letters and numbersp.75
2.2.12.1.Trademark applications consisting of a single letter or numberp.75
2.2.12.2.Trademark applications consisting of two or more letters or numbersp.77
2.2.12.3.Trademark applications consisting of letter-number combinationsp.77
2.2.13.City names or well-known place names standing alonep.78
2.2.14.Signs to be refused for not creating a trademark perceptionp.81
2.2.15.Well-known book titlesp.82
2.2.16.Applications consisting solely of country namesp.83
2.2.16.1.Country name + device elementp.84
2.2.17.Position trademarksp.85
NumberTitlePage
3.Turkish Industrial Property Code Article 5/1-Cp.89
3.1.General principlesp.89
3.1.1.Assessment of the sign subject to the application as a wholep.89
3.1.2.Assessment of descriptiveness based on the perception of the “relevant consumer”p.89
3.1.3.Assessment of descriptiveness in relation to the relevant goods/servicesp.90
3.1.4.Assessment of descriptiveness within the framework of the specific circumstances and current conditions of the casep.91
3.2.Descriptive signsp.92
3.2.1.Writing the descriptive expression in different characters and fontsp.94
3.2.1.1.Word elements in the trademarkp.95
3.2.1.1.1.Typefacep.95
3.2.1.1.2.Combination with coloursp.96
3.2.1.1.3.Combination with punctuation marks and other symbolsp.96
3.2.1.2.Different positioning of word elementsp.96
3.2.2.Words and word combinationsp.97
3.2.3.Applications consisting of product names related to servicesp.100
3.2.4.Applications describing the place or the person producing/selling a goodp.101
3.2.5.Descriptive words in foreign languagesp.103
3.2.6.Word combinations in different languagesp.107
3.2.6.1.Descriptiveness of a word as used in Turkish after originating from a foreign languagep.108
3.2.6.2.Applications filed in other alphabetsp.108
3.2.7.Descriptive figurative elementsp.110
3.2.8.Figurative elements and descriptive wordsp.111
3.2.9.Figurative componentsp.117
3.2.10.Misspelled words (misspellings)p.118
3.2.11.Repetition of letters in descriptive wordsp.119
3.2.12.Applications containing geographical place namesp.120
3.2.12.1.Fundamental criteria to be considered when assessing descriptiveness of applications containing geographical place namesp.122
3.2.12.2.Applications containing a geographical place name alone / as the main elementp.127
3.2.12.3.Applications consisting of a geographical place name + name of goods/services or sectorp.127
3.2.12.4.Applications consisting of country names as geographical place namesp.131
3.2.12.4.1.Applications consisting of a country name + non-distinctive or descriptive elementp.132
3.2.12.4.2.Applications consisting of a figurative element + country namep.132
3.2.12.4.3.Applications consisting of a country name + expressions such as “language school” / “language center”p.134
3.2.13.Applications created by adding the initials of non-distinctive / descriptive expressions to the signp.138
3.2.14.Possessive suffixes used together with non-distinctive / descriptive expressionsp.139
3.2.14.1.Applications containing the prefix “my”p.141
3.2.15.Applications consisting of an internet domain namep.142
3.2.16.Applications arranged in the form of a hashtag (social media tag)p.144
3.2.17.Expressions such as “saray”, “dünyası”, “world”, “land” used together with descriptive wordsp.144
3.2.18.Applications containing the words Türkiye, Türk, Turkish, Euro, Europe, Europeanp.146
3.2.19.Applications in the form of “alo + product / sector / service name”p.148
3.2.20.Applications arranged in the form of “non-distinctive / descriptive expression + matik / matic”p.149
3.2.21.Applications containing non-distinctive / descriptive expressions used together with words indicating qualityp.150
3.2.22.Applications in the form of “moda / fashion + non-distinctive / descriptive expression”p.153
3.2.23.Applications in the form of “e- + non-distinctive / descriptive expression”p.154
3.2.24.Use of non-distinctive / descriptive expressions in reduplicated form in the applicationp.156
3.2.25.Applications consisting of expressions related to the time or frequency of use of the goods or the time when the service is providedp.157
3.2.26.Names of hotels, newspapers, magazines and airportsp.158
3.2.27.Applications in the form of “… series / series”, “model …”, “… model”p.160
3.2.28.Applications in the form of “… institute”, “… academy”, “… academy”p.161
3.2.29.Applications consisting of names given by the applicant to an innovation / new practice / new technology created by themp.162
3.2.30.Applications consisting of “multi + non-distinctive / descriptive expression”p.163
3.2.31.Applications containing INN namesp.165
3.2.32.Applications in the form of “non-distinctive / descriptive expression + here”p.166
3.2.33.Applications in the form of “new generation + non-distinctive / descriptive expression”p.169
3.2.34.Applications in the form of “green + non-distinctive / descriptive expression”p.171
3.2.35.Applications in the form of “non-distinctive / descriptive expression + plus”, “plus + non-distinctive / descriptive expression”p.173
3.2.36.Applications consisting solely of numbersp.174
3.2.37.Applications consisting of a single letterp.175
3.2.38.Applications consisting of television program namesp.175
3.2.39.Applications indicating the subject/content of the goods for which registration is sought (books, films, documentaries etc.)p.176
3.2.40.Applications arranged in the form of “easy + non-distinctive / descriptive expression”, “kolay + non-distinctive / descriptive expression”p.177
3.2.41.Applications consisting of color namesp.177
3.2.42.Applications in the form of “eco / eko + non-distinctive / descriptive expression”p.178
3.2.43.Applications in the form of “non-distinctive / descriptive expression + arbitrary”p.178
3.2.44.Naming conventions used by banks/internet providers for their service packagesp.179
3.2.45.Applications consisting of company names – trade names – business names whose core element is descriptive in naturep.180
3.2.46.Applications containing the expressions akıllı, smart, güvenli, hesaplıp.181
3.2.47.Marks using the expressions “en iyi / best / the best”p.184
3.2.48.Applications consisting of “mini + non-distinctive / descriptive expression”p.185
3.2.49.Applications consisting of “universal / evrensel + non-distinctive / descriptive expression”p.185
NumberTitlePage
4.Turkish Industrial Property Code Article 5/1-Çp.187
4.1.General principlesp.187
4.1.1.Determination of identity or similarity to the extent of being indistinguishablep.188
4.1.1.1.Identityp.188
4.1.1.2.Similarity to the extent of being indistinguishablep.192
4.1.1.2.1.Evaluation of similarity based on the overall impression left by the signsp.194
4.1.1.2.2.Evaluation of similarity based on distinctive elementsp.199
4.1.2.Same or same type of goods or servicesp.218
4.1.3.Evaluation of similarity in special casesp.221
4.1.3.1.Word marks with phonetic similarityp.221
4.1.3.1.1.Similarity of signs differing only by the letters x – ksp.223
4.1.3.1.2.Similarity of signs differing only by the letters k and cp.226
4.1.3.1.3.Similarity assessment of applications containing letter repetitionp.227
4.1.3.2.Similarity assessment in word marks containing suffixesp.230
4.1.3.2.1.Similarity of applications containing the suffixes “oğlu”, “kızı”, “zade”, “oğulları”, “ler”, “lar”p.230
4.1.3.2.2.Similarity of applications containing possessive suffixesp.231
4.1.3.2.3.Similarity of applications containing the English possessive suffix “’s”p.232
4.1.3.2.4.Similarity of applications in which the English plural suffix “-s” is addedp.234
4.1.3.3.Similarity of applications containing weakly distinctive expressions such as optimum / global / star / idealp.236
4.1.3.4.Similarity of applications containing the English expression “by”p.238
4.1.3.5.Similarity assessment of applications containing the English expression “the”p.240
4.1.3.6.Similarity of applications containing suffixes such as “-san”, “-mak”, “-pen”, “-tech”, “-med”, “-dent”p.241
4.1.3.7.Similarity assessment in applications ending with “tech – tek” or “tek – tec”p.242
4.1.3.8.Similarity assessment of applications containing the English expression “my”p.243
4.1.3.9.Similarity assessment of applications containing the words “grup” – “group”p.243
4.1.3.10.Similarity assessment of applications containing the expression “… holding”p.247
4.1.3.11.Similarity assessment of applications containing the expressions “Türk” and “Euro”p.248
4.1.3.12.Similarity assessment of applications containing the expression “plus”p.249
4.1.3.13.Similarity assessment of applications containing the expressions “max”, “maks”p.250
4.1.3.14.Similarity assessment of applications containing the expression “extra/ekstra”p.251
4.1.3.15.Similarity assessment of applications containing the expression “pure”p.252
4.1.3.16.Similarity assessment of applications containing the expression “ultra”p.253
4.1.3.17.Similarity assessment of applications containing the expression “soft”p.254
4.1.3.18.Similarity assessment of applications containing the expression “life”p.254
4.1.3.19.Similarity assessment of applications containing the expressions “lux/delux/premium”p.255
4.1.3.20.Similarity assessment of applications containing the expression “smart”p.256
4.1.3.21.Similarity assessment of applications containing the expressions “home/house”p.257
4.1.3.22.Similarity assessment of applications containing the expressions “collection/dekor”p.259
4.1.3.23.Similarity assessment of applications containing the prefixes “has”, “öz”, “yeni”p.260
4.1.3.24.Similarity assessment of expressions that change position within a word or in word combinationsp.261
4.1.3.25.Similarity assessment of applications consisting of words in which at least one letter is in the form of a figurep.261
4.1.3.26.Similarity assessment when signs are separated by the symbol “&”p.265
4.1.3.27.Similarity assessment of letter groups/words separated by standard punctuation marks such as “.”, “-”, “,”p.266
4.1.3.28.Similarity assessment of applications containing a geographical place namep.268
4.1.3.28.1.Province names or well-known place namesp.268
4.1.3.28.1.1.Usep.269
4.1.3.28.1.2.Combined usep.269
4.1.3.29.Similarity assessment in slogan marksp.276
4.1.3.30.Similarity assessment of applications consisting of reduplicationsp.277
4.1.3.31.Similarity assessment of applications containing expressions such as “vakfı / derneği / birliği” (foundation / association / union)p.278
4.1.3.32.Similarity assessment of applications containing expressions such as “okul / kolej / akademi / eğitim kurumları” (school / college / academy / educational institutions)p.279
4.1.3.33.Similarity assessment where the descriptive element indicating a profession appears before the distinctive element in the applicationp.281
4.1.3.34.Similarity assessment in applications consisting of a person’s name and surnamep.282
4.1.3.35.Similarity assessment where the same numbers are written in digits and in wordsp.283
4.1.3.36.Similarity assessment in applications where numbers and letters are used togetherp.283
4.1.3.37.Similarity assessment of applications consisting of two or three lettersp.284
4.1.3.38.Similarity assessment where a group of letters formed from the initial letters of the words making up the application also appears in the applicationp.286
4.1.3.39.Similarity assessment of applications consisting of a single letter and a numeralp.287
4.1.3.40.Similarity assessment of applications consisting of a trade namep.288
4.1.3.41.Similarity assessment in applications consisting of a figurative elementp.290
4.1.3.42.Similarity of the figurative element in applications consisting of a word + figurative combinationp.291
4.1.3.43.Similarity assessment of applications for color marks consisting of a color or a combination of colorsp.292
4.2.Similarity assessment in the case of jointly owned applicationsp.292
NumberTitlePage
5.Turkish Industrial Property Code Article 5/1-Dp.294
5.1.Signs used by everyone in the field of tradep.295
5.2.Signs used to indicate membership in a particular profession, art, or trade groupp.297
NumberTitlePage
6.Turkish Industrial Property Code Article 5/1-Ep.299
6.1.Shapes or other characteristics arising from the nature of the goodsp.299
6.2.Shapes or other characteristics that are necessary to obtain a technical resultp.300
6.3.Shapes or other characteristics that give the goods their essential valuep.304
NumberTitlePage
7.Turkish Industrial Property Code Article 5/1-Fp.305
7.1.Deceptiveness regarding geographical originp.307
7.2.Deceptiveness relating to signs that may pose a health risk if usedp.310
7.3.Signs that are deceptive due to the nature of the goodsp.312
7.4.Applications consisting of or giving the impression of official institution namesp.314
NumberTitlePage
8.Turkish Industrial Property Code Article 5/1-Gp.315
8.1.Scope of protectionp.317
8.1.1.Signs and emblems of statesp.317
8.1.2.Flags of statesp.318
8.1.3.Imitation of coats of arms, flags of dynasties and other state emblemsp.322
8.1.4.Limitation of protection for control and guarantee signsp.323
8.1.5.Signs of international intergovernmental organizationsp.324
8.1.6.Black-and-white representations of signs protected under the provisionp.326
8.1.7.Representations in different colors of signs protected under the provisionp.328
8.2.Research to be conducted under Article 5/1-(g)p.329
NumberTitlePage
9.Turkish Industrial Property Code Article 5/1-Ğp.330
9.1.General overviewp.330
9.2.Other signs that concern the public and have become public property due to historical or cultural valuep.330
9.2.1.Signs containing the names of prominent Turkish figures, artists, and authors that have become public propertyp.331
9.2.2.Signs containing the expressions “Osmanlı İmparatorluğu/Devleti/Ottoman Empire” or the Ottoman state coat of armsp.335
9.2.3.Signs containing photographs and images of historical and cultural structuresp.336
9.2.4.Signs containing the names and surnames of the presidents of the Republic of Türkiyep.338
9.2.5.Events or figures of significance in terms of historical and cultural valuep.339
9.3.Signs containing coats of arms, insignia or designations for which registration permission has not been granted by the competent authoritiesp.341
NumberTitlePage
10.Turkish Industrial Property Code Article 5/1-Hp.343
10.1.General overviewp.343
10.2.Signs used solely as a religious term or symbol in society or signs that directly evoke a religious associationp.343
10.3.Signs that have a religious meaning or content but are used in other fields or do not directly evoke a religious associationp.345
10.4.Signs containing the names and titles of religious officialsp.346
10.5.Signs containing the names and/or visuals of sacred placesp.347
10.6.Signs containing the names of religions or denominationsp.351
10.7.Signs containing religious concepts or the names of religious figuresp.351
NumberTitlePage
11.Turkish Industrial Property Code Article 5/1-Ip.354
11.1.Concept of public orderp.354
11.2.Concept of public moralityp.355
11.3.Application of the provisionp.357
NumberTitlePage
12.Turkish Industrial Property Code Article 5/1-İp.361
12.1.General overviewp.361
12.2.Situations falling within the scope of Article 5/1-(i)p.361
12.3.Situations not falling within the scope of Article 5/1-(i)p.362
12.4.Assessment of identical or comparable goodsp.362
12.5.Application criteriap.364
12.5.1.Case where the trademark application consists solely of a registered geographical indicationp.364
12.5.2.Case where the trademark application contains, in addition to a distinctive word or figurative element, a registered geographical indication or an expression that evokes the registered geographical indicationp.366
12.5.2.1.Limitation of the goods listp.367
12.5.3.Case where the application contains an expression close to the full name of the geographical indicationp.368
12.5.4.Case where the application contains, not in order, the elements constituting the full name of the geographical indicationp.370
12.5.5.Case where the trademark application consists of or contains the geographical-source-indicating part of a registered geographical indicationp.373
12.5.5.1.Case where the trademark application consists solely of the geographical-source-indicating part of a registered geographical indicationp.373
12.5.5.2.Case where the trademark application contains the geographical-source-indicating part of a registered geographical indicationp.373
12.5.6.Case where the trademark application consists solely of or contains an equivalent adjective/noun indicating the geographical source of a registered geographical indicationp.375
12.5.6.1.Case where the trademark application consists of an equivalent adjective/noun corresponding to the place-name part of the registered geographical indicationp.375
12.5.6.2.Case where the trademark application contains an equivalent adjective/noun corresponding to the place-name part of the registered geographical indicationp.376
12.5.7.Case where the trademark application consists of or contains the translation of a registered geographical indicationp.378
12.5.7.1.Case where the trademark application consists of the translation of a registered geographical indicationp.378
12.5.7.2.Case where the trademark application contains the translation of a registered geographical indicationp.378
12.5.8.Case where the trademark application contains more than one registered geographical indicationp.379

Guideline for the Examination of Article 6 of the Industrial Property Code No. 6769​

NumberTitlePage
1.Introductionp.380
2.Comparison of goods and servicesp.383
2.1.Role of the Nice Classification in the comparison of goods/servicesp.387
2.2.Definition and determination of the scope of goods and servicesp.387
2.2.1.Definition of goods and servicesp.387
2.2.1.1.Goodsp.387
2.2.2.Determination of the scope of goods and servicesp.389
2.3.Comparison of goods and servicesp.392
2.3.1.Identityp.392
2.3.2.Similarity of goods and servicesp.393
2.4.Examples of goods–services similarityp.408
2.4.1.Clothing (class 25) and home textile products (class 24)p.409
2.4.2.Clothing, footwear and headwear (class 25)p.411
2.4.3.Clothing (class 25) and woven or non-woven fabrics (class 24) and processed or unprocessed leathers and hides, artificial leathers, soles, lining leathers (class 18)p.411
2.4.4.Clothing (class 25) and bags, wallets, suitcases (class 18), jewellery, watches (class 14), glasses, sunglasses (class 9) and perfumes (class 3)p.412
2.4.5.Clothing, footwear, headwear (class 25) and gymnastic and sporting articles in class 28p.414
2.4.6.Clothing (class 25) and tailoring services (class 40)p.414
2.4.7.Pharmaceutical preparations for human and animal health (class 5) and dietetic substances adapted for medical and veterinary use; dietary supplements, food (nutritional) supplements for humans and animals; medical slimming preparations, medicinal herbs and medicinal herbal beverages (class 5)p.415
2.4.8.Food products (goods included in classes 29, 30 and 31)p.415
2.4.9.Teas, iced teas, coffee or cocoa-based beverages, chocolate-based beverages (class 30) and mineral waters, spring waters, table waters, sodas and vegetable and fruit juices, their concentrates and essences, soft drinks (class 32)p.420
2.4.10.Alcoholic beverages (class 33) and non-alcoholic beverages (class 32)p.421
2.4.11.Alcoholic beverages (class 33) and beers (class 32)p.422
2.4.12.Foods and beverages (goods in classes 29, 30 and 32) and food and drink provision services (class 43)p.423
2.4.13.Food and drink provision services (class 43) and temporary accommodation services (class 43)p.427
2.4.14.Electronic publications (class 09) and printed publications (class 16)p.427
2.4.15.Construction materials included in class 19 and construction services (class 37)p.427
2.4.16.Construction services (class 37) and engineering services, engineering and architectural design services (class 42)p.428
2.4.17.Printed documents (class 16) and education and training services and services relating to preparing magazines, books, newspapers etc. for printing and delivering them to readers (class 41)p.429
2.4.18.Stationery and materials for education and training (class 16) and education and training services (class 41)p.430
2.4.19.Financial and monetary services (class 36) and insurance services (class 36)p.430
2.4.20.Financial and monetary services (class 36) and real estate brokerage, consultancy and management services (class 36)p.431
2.4.21.Financial and monetary services (class 36) and construction services (class 37)p.431
2.4.22.Financial and monetary services (class 36) and credit cards, bank cards (class 9)p.431
2.4.23.Real estate brokerage, consultancy and management services (class 36) and construction services (class 37)p.432
2.4.24.Non-textile wall coverings, wallpapers (class 27) and paints (class 2)p.432
2.4.25.Class 8 instruments used for beauty and personal care and class 21 shaving brushes, hairbrushes, combs, and beauty care services in class 44p.433
2.4.26.Forks, spoons, knives including those made of precious metals, and non-electric cutting, chopping, peeling kitchen tools (class 8) and non-electric household and kitchen utensils including those made of precious metals (excluding cutlery): tableware, containers, non-electric cooking utensils (class 21)p.433
2.4.27.Computers (class 9) and software (class 9)p.434
2.4.28.Computers, software (class 9) and computer services (class 42)p.434
2.4.29.Apparatus for recording, transmitting or reproducing sound and images (class 9) and telecommunication services–internet service provision (class 38)p.435
2.4.30.Chemicals used in agriculture, horticulture and forestry (class 1) and fertilizers (class 1)p.436
2.4.31.Fertilizers and chemicals used in agriculture, horticulture and forestry (class 1) and substances for destroying harmful insects, plants, fungi (class 5)p.436
2.4.32.Perfumery; cosmetic products (excluding medicated cosmetics) and soaps (class 3) and pharmaceutical preparations for human and animal health, medicated cosmetics (class 5)p.436
2.4.33.Bleaching and cleaning preparations, detergents, laundry bleach, fabric softeners, stain removers, dishwashing preparations and soaps (excluding medicated soaps) (class 3) and disinfectants, antiseptics, medicinal detergents, medicated soaps, disinfectant soaps, antibacterial hand lotions (class 5)p.437
2.4.34.Stationery, office, educational, writing, drawing, painting and art materials (excluding furniture and devices): stationery-type paper products, adhesives, pens, erasers, tapes, craft cardboard, writing papers, copying papers, cash register paper rolls, drawing tools, blackboards, paints (class 16) and games and toys (class 28)p.438
2.4.35.Construction materials in classes 6, 17 and 19p.439
2.4.36.Baby carriages, strollers (class 12) and baby carriers, indoor playpens, cribs, walkers (class 20)p.439
2.4.37.Medical services (class 44) and pharmaceutical preparations for humans and animals, medical and veterinary chemical products, medical and veterinary radioactive chemical substances, medicated cosmetics (class 5)p.440
2.4.38.Medical services (class 44) and surgical, medical, dental and veterinary instruments, devices and furniture; orthopedic items: medical corsets, orthopedic footwear, elastic and supportive bandages (class 10)p.441
2.4.39.Liquid and gaseous fuels: gasoline, diesel, LPG, natural gas, fuel oil, and their non-chemical additives; industrial oils, greases, cutting fluids, dust absorbing–wetting–binding substances (class 4) and vehicle service station services–maintenance, repair and fuel filling (class 37)p.441
2.4.40.Motor land vehicles (including motorcycles and mopeds) and motors, clutches and transmission parts for these vehicles; belts and chains; gears; brakes, brake discs and pads; chassis; bodywork; suspensions; shock absorbers; transmissions; steering wheels; rims (class 12) and vehicle service station services–maintenance, repair and fuel filling (class 37)p.442
2.4.41.Pharmaceutical preparations for humans and animals, medical and veterinary chemical products, radioactive chemicals for medical and veterinary use, medicated cosmetics, and dental products (class 5) and surgical, medical, dental and veterinary instruments, devices and furniture (class 10)p.443
2.4.42.Dental care products: toothpastes, tooth polishing and whitening preparations, non-medicated mouthwashes (class 3) and toothbrushes, electric toothbrushes, dental floss (class 21)p.443
2.4.43.Retail and wholesale services enabling customers to conveniently view and purchase goods (class 35)p.444
2.4.44.Comparison of parts and equipment with final productsp.448
2.4.45.Comparison of raw materials and semi-processed goods with finished goodsp.449
2.4.46.Comparison of repair, maintenance and installation services with goodsp.450
NumberTitlePage
3.Relevant consumer segment and level of attentionp.451
3.1.Consumersp.451
3.1.1.The public at large (average consumers)p.455
3.1.2.Professional (specialised) consumer groupp.457
3.2.Level of attentionp.458
3.2.1.High level of attentionp.462
3.2.2.Low level of attentionp.469
NumberTitlePage
4.Distinctiveness of the earlier trademarkp.471
4.1.Concept of distinctivenessp.473
4.2.Determining the distinctive character of the earlier trademarkp.474
4.2.1.Inherent distinctivenessp.480
4.2.2.Enhanced distinctivenessp.481
4.2.3.The situation of trademarks that have acquired distinctiveness through usep.484
NumberTitlePage
5.Comparison of signsp.485
5.1.Identity of signsp.487
5.2.Similarity of signsp.493
5.2.1.Concepts of dominant and distinctive elements and identification of such elementsp.494
5.2.2.Comparison of signsp.502
5.2.3.Effects of the distinctive character and perceptibility of similar and differing elements within the signs on the assessment of sign similarityp.577
5.2.4.Other principles considered in the comparison of signsp.590
5.3.Circumstances where sign similarity is not foundp.598
5.3.1.Absence of common elementsp.598
5.3.2.Cases where, despite the presence of common elements, sign similarity is not foundp.599
5.3.3.Cases where elements that are negligible within the sign constitute the common elementp.599
5.3.4.Cases where the common element is stylisedp.601
5.3.5.Cases where non-distinctive elements constitute the common elementp.603
NumberTitlePage
6.Joint assessment of the factors used in determining the likelihood of confusions.605
6.1.Principle of interdependences.607
6.2.Impression retained in memorys.609
6.3.Effects of the purchasing methods of goods and services on the assessment of likelihood of confusions.610
6.4.Effect of non-distinctive or weakly distinctive common elements on the assessment of likelihood of confusions.614
6.4.1.Cases where common elements have a low degree of distinctivenesss.616
6.4.2.Cases where common elements are non-distinctives.620
6.5.Marks creating a series-mark impressions.623
6.6.Likelihood of associations.625
NumberTitlePage
7.Frequently encountered or special circumstances in the assessment of likelihood of confusionp.629
7.1.Marks consisting of or containing a first name–surnamep.629
7.1.1.Second marks used together with a person’s first name and surnamep.636
7.2.Sub-brands / second brands used together with an umbrella / parent brandp.639
7.3.Presence of a common word element in signs consisting of multiple word elementsp.642
7.4.Assessment of likelihood of confusion where the common element is a geographical place namep.648
7.5.Marks containing slogansp.653
7.6.Transposed (rearranged) wordsp.655
7.7.Case where one of the signs compared is in domain-name formatp.656
7.8.Pharmaceutical marksp.660
7.9.Comparison of marks consisting of a single letter or numeralp.662
7.10.Short signsp.665
7.11.Comparison of colour marksp.668
7.12.Comparison of three-dimensional marksp.668